Some Of Our Books


« A New Survey | Main | Susan Wolf and Meaningfulness »

June 13, 2011


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I wonder if those who answered 'yes' to Q5 had a weaker "some sense of obligation" in mind than they did when answering Q4?

Even if everyone shares your intuition that the securable intention condition applies to an important sense of objective obligation, they might still answer 'yes' to Q5 so long as they are more liberal than us in what other senses of 'obligation' they countenance. (E.g., if they also think there's a sense of 'objective obligation' corresponding to, say, the best physically possible outcome.)

So there's some risk here that the questions weren't necessarily getting at what you wanted...

Hi Richard,

I hope that's what is going on, and it's not just that I have wacky intuitions.

I'm sure that there are many design flaws with my survey. It would be interested in hearing from those who took the survey whether the relevant sense of obligation changed as they proceeded through the questions.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Ethics at PEA Soup

PPE at PEA Soup

Like PEA Soup

Search PEA Soup


  • Unless otherwise indicated, the views expressed in any given post reflect the opinion of only that individual who posted the particular entry or comment.